Curt Cignetti shows anything possible in new era of college sports
By Pat Harty
IOWA CITY, Iowa – Indiana head football coach Curt Cignetti, in less than two seasons, has destroyed the it-could-never-be-accomplished-here narrative.
He has taken one of the traditionally worst football programs in Big Ten history, maybe even worse than academically burdened Northwestern, and turned it into a super power in less than two seasons.
Cignetti has made Indiana a more appealing job than Penn State, at least for him since Indiana is willing to pay Cignetti $11.6 million annually over eight years to coach the Hoosiers moving forward.
Men’s basketball will forever have its place on top of the sports hierarchy at Indiana, but right now, football has center stage, and deservedly so.
Indiana is 7-0, including a hard-fought 20-15 victory over Iowa on Sept. 27 at Kinnick Stadium, is ranked second nationally and showing no signs of letting up as Cignetti continues to oversee what is arguably the greatest turnaround in the history of Big Ten football.
Northwestern’s rebuild under Gary Barnett in the mid-1990s was stunning, the way in which he took a traditional Big Ten doormat with high academic standards and turned it into a Big Ten power, winning back-to-back conference titles in 1995 and 1996.
Barnett would go on to spend two more seasons at Northwestern, both of which were losing seasons, before taking the Colorado job.

The Wildcats finished 5-7 in 1997 and 3-9 in 1998, including 0-8 in conference play.
Colorado apparently still felt that Barnett was worthy of being hired probably because he had accomplished the unimaginable by winning two Big Ten titles as the Northwestern head coach.
However, the Wildcats faded fast under Barnett, showing how hard it is for certain programs to sustain success.
Northwestern, which is currently 5-2, has been up and down since the Barnett rebuild, but it hasn’t sunk to the depths it fell to in the 1970s and 1980s.
Indiana, meanwhile, is 18-2 under the 64-year-old Cignetti, who has been winning games at a spectacular rate throughout his head coaching career, but just not at places that get much attention until Indiana hired him.
Cignetti had a 52-9 record in five seasons as the head coach for James Madison from 2019 to 2023.
That was enough to convince Indiana to hire him, and when it happened, there were probably lots of college football fans, and maybe even some Indiana fans, that didn’t give much thought to it being a home run hire.
Cignetti’s hiring has actually been a grand slam, home run hire, better than anyone except probably Cignetti could have imagined.
There wasn’t really a rebuild because the Hoosiers hit the ground running under Cignetti, and passing and tackling and doing whatever it takes to win games.
Cignetti took a bunch of his players from James Madison and made them a significant part of the foundation at Indiana.
He also used the transfer portal to find his starting quarterback for this season and for last season, and in each case, Cignetti hit the jackpot.
Kurtis Rourke made second-team all-Big Ten as Indiana’s starting quarterback last season, while current starter Fernando Mendoza has a chance to make first-team All-Big Ten, and is also considered a serious Heisman Trophy candidate.
Rourke transferred to Indiana from Ohio, while Mendoza transferred from Cal-Berkeley.
An argument could certainly be made that it’s much easier to rebuild a program now compared to when Hayden Fry and Kirk Ferentz rebuilt the Iowa program, and when Barnett rebuilt Northwestern.
But on the other hand, the pressure to win right away has put head coaches on much shorter leashes these days.
And if it’s so easy to rebuild now with the transfer portal and with NIL, then how do you explain the current messes at Wisconsin, Florida and Florida State?
Indiana is vastly superior to all three of those teams right now because Indiana hired the right head coach, while the other three apparently didn’t.
Indiana also has made a significant financial investment in football, helped of course, by the House v. NCAA settlement that was approved in June, ending three separate federal antitrust lawsuits, all of which claimed the NCAA was illegally limiting the earning power of college athletes.
The NCAA has agreed to pay nearly $2.8 billion in back damages over the next 10 years to athletes who competed in college at any time from 2016 through present day. Moving forward, each school can pay its athletes up to a certain limit.
The annual cap started at roughly $20.5 million per school in 2025-26 and will increase every year during the decade-long deal. These new payments are in addition to scholarships and other benefits the athletes already receive.

Billionaire Mark Cuban, a 1981 Indiana graduate, also has reportedly made a recent and substantial donation to his alma mater in which football is expected to benefit from greatly.
And while having a billionaire in your corner certainly helps, it still comes down to hiring the right head coach.
Indiana was smart to lock down Cignetti right away with Penn State and Florida now looking to hire a new head coach.
Both of those programs certainly have more tradition and better recruiting bases than Indiana.
But that doesn’t matter as much anymore because the chance to make money has changed the landscape and the way people think.
Indiana has suddenly become a destination job.
But the question is will it last beyond Cignetti?
Indiana hopes it won’t have to answer that question for at least eight more years.
Cignetti, with his brashness and unfiltered talk, has changed the playing field by showing that almost any program can win big if the right pieces are in place; those pieces being the right head coach and the right amount of money to compete.
Iowa will be hiring a new head football sooner than later since Kirk Ferentz is 70 years old and in his 27th season as head coach.
And while Ferentz has given no indication that he is even considering retiring, it’ll happen in the foreseeable future.
So, it’s reasonable to assume that Iowa Athletic Director Beth Goetz has watched closely as Indiana soars to unprecedented heights under Cignetti.
Once lowly Indiana has devised the blueprint that other schools will now try to emulate.
But again, it starts with hiring the right head coach and with raising enough money so the head coach can work his magic, on and off the field.