Iowa men’s basketball isn’t cursed, but some unfavorable streaks continue to fester
By Pat Harty
IOWA CITY, Iowa – A friend of mine, who shall remain anonymous, has sort of convinced himself that the Iowa men’s basketball team is cursed.
He probably feels that way even more now with Iowa having lost its final three regular-season games.
It’s partly a joke, but also his way of coping with some of the frustrating streaks that have festered within the Iowa men’s basketball program, and three in particular, including Iowa having not advanced to the NCAA Sweet 16 since the 1998-99 season.
The Iowa men’s basketball team also hasn’t won a share of the Big Ten regular-season title since the 1978-1979 season, or the title outright since 1970 when Ralph Miller’s legendary “Six Pack” finished 14-0 in conference play, and when rock icons Jim Morrison, Janis Joplin and Jimi Hendrix were all still alive.
First-year Iowa head coach Ben McCollum was asked at a recent press conference if he knew when Iowa last won a share of the Big Ten regular-season title, and he mistakenly guessed 1985.
When told that it was the 1978-79 season, McCollum, who was born in 1981 in Iowa City, said:
“Before I was born.”
McCollum was then asked how important it would be to end the Big Ten regular-season championship drought as he moves forward at Iowa.
The Hawkeyes finished 10-10 in conference play this season and 20-11 overall, and will be the No. 9 seed in the Big Ten Tournament, which starts Tuesday in Chicago.
“I think that’s the hardest thing to do,” McCollum said of winning a regular-season conference title. “I really do. I think the regular-season conference championships are the hardest. I think they’re harder than the national title.

“I think the difference is that the national title requires a little luck and there’s only one of them. And we’ve won national titles at division two. I thought our regular-season conference title meant more and was more difficult to be able to win. That’s just always been my theory because it’s over time, it’s through injuries, it’s through sickness, it’s through other’s peoples’ injuries, it’s through playing teams that know who are and stuff like that.”
McCollum won four Division II national titles over 14 seasons at Northwest Missouri State. He also won the Missouri Valley regular-season and tournament titles in his only season as the Drake head coach last season.
And even though McCollum recently learned exactly how long it’s been since Iowa last won at least a share of a Big Ten regular-season conference title; he doesn’t consider it extra motivation.
“Not really; I’d want to do it regardless if it was last year if they won a conference championship,” he said.
Iowa’s NCAA Tournament woes is partly what led to Fran McCaffery being let go as head coach the day after last season ended.
Despite how hard it is to win a regular-season conference title, more attention is focused on postseason success as the NCAA Tournament continues to grow in stature and influence.
McCollum probably wouldn’t have to win a regular-season conference title at Iowa to be considered a success if his teams were to start making runs in the NCAA Tournament.
At some point, though, McCollum probably would have to lead Iowa to at least the NCAA Sweet 16 to keep his seat from getting warm.
Fran McCaffery’s inability to do that was one of the biggest factors in Iowa’s declining attendance, and then the low attendance was a key factor in Fran McCaffery being dismissed despite being Iowa’s all-time winningest head coach.
The Iowa men’s basketball team isn’t cursed, but if believing it is helps you cope, then so be it because to not win even a share of the conference title for over four decades is a lot for fans to handle.
You would’ve thought after all these years that Iowa would have won a regular-season conference title just from the law of averages.
It would be different and easier to explain if Iowa were a traditional basement dweller, but that isn’t the case.

Iowa has had some really good teams since it last won a share of the conference title in 1979; most notably the team a year later that advanced to the 1980 Final Four under head coach Lute Olson.
Iowa hasn’t been back to the Final Four since then.
Because of its postseason success, it’s easy to overlook that Iowa’s 1980 Final Four team only finished fourth in the Big Ten regular-season conference standings while playing part of the season without star point guard Ronnie Lester, who was hobbled by a knee injury.
Finishing fourth probably has added to the mystique of Iowa’s 1980 Final Four team as it shows that anything is possible.
I used to think that Iowa would win a Big Ten regular-season title while covering the beat, but now after more than three decades on the beat, I’m not as sure.
My prediction is that Iowa will reach the Sweet 16 before it wins a Big Ten regular-season title, because as McCollum said, one is more difficult than the other.
Big Ten Tournament titles are a nice prize to win along the way, but they aren’t enough to keep your job as Fran McCaffery would ultimately learn. He led Iowa to the Big Ten Tournament title in 2022 , but was then fired three years later, and after failing to make the NCAA Tournament in back-to-back seasons.
Success in the NCAA Tournament is what head coaches are ultimately judged on these days.
Of course, the regular season still matters because it determines which teams make the NCAA Tournament.
It is widely believed that Iowa already has accomplished enough to make the NCAA Tournament, even if it were to lose on Wednesday in the Big Ten Tournament where Iowa will face either Oregon or Maryland.
I said before the season that if Iowa were to make the NCAA Tournament, then year one under McCollum would be a considered a success no matter how it happened.
Of course, nobody wants to back into the NCAA Tournament, but at this early stage under McCollum, just getting in the tournament is all that matters.
McCollum gets a pass this season, any maybe even next season, if in both seasons, Iowa falls short of making the Sweet 16.
At some point, though, that streak will hang over McCollum’s head as it did with Fran McCaffery, who didn’t like to talk about Iowa’s historical woes, saying much of it happened before he arrived.
But after 14 seasons as head coach, Fran McCaffery became a part of Iowa’s history, and that is eventually what led to his demise.
March Madness has so much power and influence that Iowa could lose on Wednesday, but it would all be forgotten, or excused, if Iowa were to make the Sweet 16.
Just winning one game in the NCAA Tournament probably would give McCollum enough goodwill to overlook an early exit from the Big Ten Tournament, or how the regular season ended.

This Iowa team obviously has some deficiencies on both offense and defense.
But it also has a star point guard in Bennett Stirtz and the ability to defend when locked in and focused.
That combination can cause problems for teams in the NCAA Tournament where guards and defense often rule.
Iowa’s 1978-79 squad finished in a three-way tie with Michigan State and Purdue for the Big Ten regular-season title. But then Iowa would go on to lose to Toledo, 74-72, in the first round of the NCAA Tournament, while the Spartans would go on to win the national championship with a sophomore point guard named Earvin “Magic” Johnson leading the way.
And while Iowa’s 1980 Final Four team has earned legendary status, the accomplishments from the season before are easy to overlook, or minimize, because of the loss to Toledo in the first round of the NCAA Tournament.
Lute Olson will forever have a special place in Hawkeye legend and lore, mostly because of the Final Four run.
But my friend, the one who believes in curses, will also point out that in addition to losing to Toledo in the first round under Olson, Iowa also lost to Wichita State in the first round in 1981 and to Idaho in the second round in 1982.
Tom Davis in 13 seasons as the Iowa head coach from 1986 to 1999 was 9-0 in NCAA Tournament first-round games, but just 3-6 in the second round.
His problem was that Iowa was usually an eight or nine seed, and would have to play a No. 1 seed in the second round.
McCollum might face the same challenge this season with Iowa projected as a nine seed.
Davis led Iowa to its last Sweet 16 appearance in 1999 when he was a lame duck coach after then-athletic director Bob Bowlsby refused to extend his contract.
Iowa only finished 9-7 in conference play that season, and then also lost to Wisconsin, 74-60, in the first round of the Big Ten Tournament.
So there wasn’t a lot of momentum heading into the NCAA Tournament.
But there was the Tom Davis storyline as he became a sympathetic figure that the players rallied around.
Iowa would go on to defeat Alabama-Birmingham and Arkansas in the first two rounds by scores of 77-64 and 82-72, respectively, before losing to eventual NCAA champion Connecticut 78-68 in the Sweet 16.
Tom Davis sort of had the last laugh at Bowlsby’s expense.
But that would also prove to be Iowa’s last trip to the Sweet 16, and now 27 years later, nobody is laughing about that, especially my friend who believes the team is cursed.
Remember, it’s his way of coping.