Process for picking teams for college playoff seems way more subjective than objective
By Pat Harty
IOWA CITY, Iowa – There seems to be a growing concern, or a fear with Hawkeye fans, that the Iowa football team, even at 10-2, would be left out of the 12-team College Playoff.
Iowa (8-2, 5-2) has to win its last two games against Illinois on Saturday in Champaign, Illinois, and against Nebraska on Nov. 27 at Kinnick Stadium to stay in the playoff discussion.
But the fear is that it won’t be enough.
The fear is that a team with more name recognition, and more tradition, will be picked over Iowa, even if that team has a 9-3 record and Iowa is 10-2.
Oregon and Ohio State both climbed above No. 15 Iowa in the latest playoff rankings, even though they both have three losses, while all three teams also defeated unranked opponents last Saturday by similar scores.
The only logical explanation is that the selection committee values name recognition perhaps more than anything else, believing that it would drive television viewers.
Because let’s face it, money is the driving force behind all these decisions.
Whether it be conference realignment or expansion, scheduling games for television or picking the teams to make the playoff; making money is what matters the most, with fairness and objectivity a distant second on the list.
Nobody associated with college athletics likes to say it out loud, but it’s true.
College football is being ruled by an unquenchable thirst to make money, and television revenue is where most of the money is made.
If Iowa at 10-2 were passed over for a 9-3 Oregon or a 9-3 Ohio State; it would mostly be because of name recognition and television drawing power.
Ohio State did defeat Iowa 31-14 on Oct. 3 in Iowa City.

But that was with Julian Sayin passing for 324 yards and three touchdowns.
Sayin is now out for the rest of the season due to an injury, and the Buckeyes aren’t the same on offense without him.
Oregon, like Iowa, is surging at the present time, but the Ducks also lost to Illinois 21-10 on Oct. 24 in Champaign.
Iowa, meanwhile, has won three straight games against Wisconsin, Northwestern and Purdue by a combined score of 82-17.
Iowa head coach Kirk Ferentz recently spoke with his players about how to handle all the playoff speculation, and his message was clear and simple:
“The basic thing is they just need to understand, really we have no input in any of this stuff other than how we play,” Ferentz said of his message to his players. “That really is where the focus needs to be. It’s my observation that people get caught up in it.
“I’m not telling other people what to do or how to do other things because that’s up to them. I get the entertainment aspect of it. But when it comes to what we’re trying to do, we’re trying to win the next game, simple as that. That’s really what we should focus on.”
Iowa might catch a break on Saturday if Illinois is down to its No. 3 quarterback.
But then again, the Illinois players might rally around their No. 3 quarterback, and around their head coach, Bret Bielema, who was an Iowa defensive lineman from 1988 to 1992, and put forth a winning effort.
Iowa looks to be slightly better than Illinois on paper, even if all the Illinois quarterbacks were healthy.
However, the selection committee might hold it against Iowa if it defeats Illinois playing with its No. 3 quarterback.
Two factors seem to be working against Iowa when it comes to playoff consideration: the previously mentioned name recognition, or the lack there of in Iowa’s case, and Iowa’s schedule.
Iowa has three wins over ranked opponents this season: a 20-19 victory over then 18th-ranked Michigan on Sept. 26 at the Big House; a 30-0 thrashing of then 25th-ranked Wisconsin on Oct. 31 at Kinnick Stadium; and a 24-10 victory over then 23rd-ranked Northwestern on Nov. 7 in Evanston, Illinois.

The problem is that none of those teams are ranked anymore and Michigan (5-5) might finish with a losing record under first-year head coach Kyle Whittingham.
Iowa treated its fans to some fine entertainment when it defeated Northern Illinois in week one and Northern Iowa in week three by scores of 40-0 and 55-0, respectively.
But those wins have very little influence.
There is a belief that Iowa would have to win its last two games by wide margins to really make an impression with the selection committee.
But if you think that would cause Kirk Ferentz to run up the score if given the opportunity, you couldn’t be more wrong as Ferentz made that point abundantly clear when asked on Tuesday about being more aggressive with his approach in order to impress the selection committee.
“If that comes up in our, back there,” Ferentz said while pointing to where his coaches have their offices and meeting rooms, “I’m not big on firing coaches, but that could be grounds for a firing. We’re just trying to win the game, and that for 28 years has been our goal, to put our guys in the best position tom win a game.
“And I’m not being judgmental towards anybody else. But hopefully, we’re going to play smart football and just try to do what’s best to win each and every game in front of us. If that’s not good enough, then it’s not good enough. I’ll live with that.”
Some Iowa fans might have grimaced when they heard what Ferentz said about running up the score because there is a belief that running up the score might be what it takes for Iowa to make the strongest impression.
Ferentz still coaches with the belief that integrity matters.
But he could soon learn the hard way that integrity doesn’t really matter if there is playoff money on the line.
The process for picking teams for the college playoff seems way more subjective than objective.
It will be the same next season, even with the playoff expanding to 24 teams.
The only difference is that teams 25 through 30 will be the ones complaining about being left out.
**********
College Football Playoff updated rankings
- Georgia(9-1)
- Utah (10-0)
- Alabama (8-2)
- UCLA (10-0)
- Texas (8-2)
- Notre Dame (9-1)
- Miami (9-1)
- Indiana (9-1)
- Tennessee (8-2)
- BYU (8-2)
- Wake Forest (9-1)
- Texas Tech (9-1)
- Oregon (7-3)
- Ohio State (7-3)
- Iowa (8-2)
- Kentucky (7-3)
- Boise State (9-1)
- USC (7-3)
- Arizona (7-3)
- Houston (7-3)
- South Carolina (6-4)
- Oklahoma (6-4)
- Louisville (7-3)
- Florida (6-4)
- Ole Miss (6-4)
**********
Iowa (8-2, 5-2) vs. Illinois (6-4, 4-3)
When: Saturday, 1:30 p.m.
Where: Champaign, Illinois, Memorial Stadium
TV: Big Ten Network
Radio: Hawkeye Radio Network
Series history: Saturday will be the 80th meeting between Iowa and Illinois — a series that began in 1899. Iowa trails the all-time series, 39-38-2, but the Hawkeyes have won 14 of the last 16 and 17 of the last 21 contests, dating back to 1996.
Iowa won the most recent meeting, 15-13, in Kinnick Stadium during the 2023 season.
The Hawkeyes are 17-21 all-time against the Fighting Illini in Champaign. Iowa has won eight of the last 11 road contests at Illinois.
The Illini won a field goal battle in 2022, winning 9-6 at Memorial Stadium. Illinois’ Fabrizio Pinton made three field goals, including the game-winner with 2:49 remaining to snap Iowa’s eight-game win streak in the series.
Head coach Kirk Ferentz is 14-4 in 18 career games against the Fighting Illini.
Hawkeye fans are all worked up and ready to scream about the lack of fairness in picking the 12 teams to make the College Football Playoff.
The Iowa football team plays at unranked Illinois on Saturday in its latest must-win game.